Scientific Roundtable Series 2: Defining “Bioactive”

Hosted by INSC

Watch Video Dec 11, 2025 10:00 am – 11:30 am ET Recording Available

Summary

The second Scientific Roundtable in this series examined the definition, interpretation, and application of the term “bioactive” within the context of human milk and infant formula. Vanessa Castagna (SciPinion) moderated the session, with panelists Paul Hanlon (Abbott Nutrition), Dennis Keefe (Exponent; Former Director of Office of Food Additive Safety, CFSAN, FDA), Manki Ho (Novonesis), and Sharon Donovan (University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign). The panel reviewed current definitions of “bioactive” and considered how this terminology could drive specific actions for driving academic research, guiding safety assessments, and evaluating suitability.

The term “bioactive” is commonly used in academic research to describe components of human milk and/or infant formula that provide effects beyond basic nutrition. In this context, the term bioactive is used to describe substances that could have physiological function that could be important to understand the link between composition and function.

Panelists agreed that understanding the reasonable mechanisms through which a substance could have physiological effects in the body is critical to evaluating their safety, and it was emphasized that safety evaluations for all infant formula ingredients already consider this. It was noted that this was consistent with guidance developed by the Institute of Medicine on the evaluation of infant formula ingredients, which explicitly stated that it was developed considering “bioactive” ingredients.

Panelists also considered whether the term would be helpful when describing the function of a substance. All ingredients added to infant formula must have one of three functions: essential nutrient, technological effect in the product (e.g., stabilizer, antioxidant), or as a “bioactive” ingredient being added for a function beyond basic nutrition. There was discussion about whether “bioactive” is the most effective term to describe this final category of ingredient.

The Roundtable concluded that more precise frameworks and sustained investment in human milk and infant nutrition research are necessary to support evidence-based decision-making and facilitate responsible innovation. Participants observed that currently, application of the term “bioactive” in infant formula may blur distinctions among safety and function, and whether another term, such as the “optional ingredient” language in the Codex Alimentarius infant formula standard, would be more useful.

Event Recording

If the video doesn’t load, you can watch on YouTube.

Panelists

Sharon Donovan, PhD

Sharon Donovan, PhD

University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign; INSC Steering Committee Co-Chair

View Bio

Professor Sharon Donovan is the Melissa M. Noel Endowed Chair in Nutrition and Health at the University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign. She received her Ph.D. in Nutrition at the University of California at Davis and completed a post-doctoral fellowship in Pediatric Endocrinology at the Stanford University School of Medicine.

Research in her laboratory focuses on the coordinated development of the gut microbiome, immune system, and cognitive development in early life. A key focus is on how human milk bioactives (human milk oligosaccharides, milk fat globule membrane, lactoferrin, and osteopontin) influence microbiome composition and immune function in neonates.

She has served as president of the American Society for Nutrition (2011–2012) and the International Society for Research on Human Milk and Lactation (2018–2020). She served on the 2020–2025 Dietary Guidelines for Americans Advisory Committee. Dr. Donovan was elected to the National Academy of Medicine in 2017 and was recently named Chair of the Food and Nutrition Board of the National Academy of Medicine.

Paul Hanlon, PhD

Paul Hanlon, PhD, DABT

Abbott; INSC Steering Committee Co-Chair

View Bio

Paul Hanlon earned his doctorate in molecular toxicology from the University of Wisconsin–Madison and is a Diplomate of the American Board of Toxicology. He is currently a Director of Regulatory Affairs at Abbott Nutrition where his duties include the evaluation of new food ingredients.

Paul is active in the food toxicology community and over the past years has authored multiple papers covering different aspects of food risk assessment, and given presentations on these topics to audiences around the world.

Manki Ho, PhD

Manki Ho, PhD, DABT

Novonesis; INSC Member

View Bio

Manki has been working in the food and nutraceutical industry since 2011. She began her career at a consulting firm, where she gained extensive expertise in the safety assessment of novel foods and food ingredients, along with the regulatory processes required to bring these products to market.

Currently, Manki works at Novonesis, a global ingredient supplier, where she is responsible for regulatory submissions to secure premarket clearance for a diverse range of ingredients, particularly those within the early life nutrition portfolio.

Manki earned her Ph.D. from the Department of Pharmacology and Toxicology at the University of Toronto, and she is a diplomate of the American Board of Toxicology (DABT).

Dennis M. Keefe, PhD

Dennis M. Keefe, PhD

Exponent; INSC Member

View Bio

Dr. Keefe has 30+ years working in FDA on food additive regulatory issues and 15+ years working on the development of international standards for food additives in the Codex Alimentarius. From 2011–2022 he was the Director of the FDA’s Office of Food Additive Safety (OFAS).

OFAS is responsible for the premarket review of food additives, color additives, and food contact substances, and manages FDA’s voluntary GRAS programs, biotechnology notifications, recycled plastics in food packaging, and foods derived from cultured animal cells.

During his tenure, major achievements included folic acid fortification of corn masa flour, removal of partially hydrogenated oils (PHOs) from foods, sodium reduction guidance, PFAS removal agreements, approval of soy leghemoglobin, and delisting lead acetate in hair coloring.

From the mid-1990s until 2011, Dr. Keefe led the Codex effort to develop the Codex General Standard for Food Additives. He is now a Senior Managing Scientist with Exponent.

Moderator

Vanessa Feher Castagna, PhD

Vanessa Feher Castagna, PhD

SciPinion; INSC Steering Committee Member

View Bio

Dr. Vanessa Feher Castagna is the Director of Food Safety and Claims at SciPinion where she is developing an expert peer-review program for food ingredient safety evaluations.

Vanessa is a PhD scientist from UC Davis, trained in microbiology and nutritional immunology with expertise in milk bioactive proteins for infant health. She has served in higher education and early-stage food biotech roles across scientific communication, regulatory affairs, clinical and preclinical research, and program management.

About the Scientific Roundtable Series

The INSC Scientific Roundtable Series provides a forum for experts from academia, government, and industry to explore foundational scientific questions that support and are parallel to the focus areas of the INSC. The Roundtables are organized in a way that drives participants towards:

  • Identifying where there is consensus on the topic;
  • Identifying where there is lack of alignment;
  • In areas where there is a lack of alignment, identifying actions that could lead to consensus.
INSC Scientific Roundtable Series 2 flyer: Defining 'Bioactive' — December 11, 2025, 10:00 am – 11:30 am ET.
Scientific Roundtable Series 2 — event flyer